Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

N Scale Insight: Derailments of the curious kind

Read the N Scale Insight column from the July 2017 Model Railroader
MRRNS0717_01
X marks the spot where the switch rod used to be. After several years of sporadic derailments at this turnout, Jim Kelly relocated it a few inches from the curve so engines would get a short straight before entering the turnout.
Roen Kellly photo

Several months ago, my operations chief Gordy Spiering and I were orbiting a couple trains on my N scale layout for a group of visitors and the same boxcar kept derailing at the west end switch in the town of Tehachapi.

In a situation like that the show must go on, so I pulled the car out of the train and waited until the visitors had left and the dust had settled to try to solve the problem. I put the car back where it had been, right behind the engine, and ran up the hill. The car derailed again in the same way at the same spot. That’s a good thing – the most difficult problems to solve are those that occur inconsistently.

The curious thing, though, was that when I backed the train up a few feet and ran at the turnout again, the car would cruise right on through. Then I’d run the train around the layout again and the car would derail at that same spot.

Finally that little light bulb above my head blinked on. The car was coming off the track at the turnout because it had derailed somewhere farther back. I’ve learned from experience that a car can run a considerable distance with a wheelset off the rails before the car finally comes off the track, usually at a turnout.

Sure enough the wheels were actually derailing at the switch exiting the Tehachapi Loop. Now I knew where the problem was, but I still didn’t know what was causing it.

I can’t honestly say that I ever did. I watched that wheel climb up and out again and again, finally replaced the coupler, and all was well.

As I’ve stated before, I body-mount all my couplers, and I usually re-use the cut-off, truck-mounted couplers to save money. [Read more about Jim’s adventures with couplers in the July 2014 and May 2013 N Scale Insight columns. – Ed.] I use Micro-Trains brand exclusively because I find them to be reliable and readily available. Studying the coupler I’d removed, I could see that the knuckle didn’t have as much side-to-side swing as my other M-Ts did. I suspect the culprit might have been an older version. Ordinarily this wouldn’t be a problem, but here it was because the car was right behind the engine.

Longer can be better. Let me explain. Micro-Trains gives you two options on its 1015/1016 couplers. (The 1015 is the universal coupler you can use on just about any locomotive or car.) For locomotives, I used the short shank versions, figuring they looked more realistic, which they did. With my fairly generous 18" minimum radius curves I figured they would operate just fine. I was wrong.

The medium-length couplers work better because of the longer reach of the shank. Because the pivot point for locomotive trucks is often an inch or more inboard, the rear end swings a long way out on a curve. With a short shank, this wide swing tends to pull the car behind the locomotive off the track.

A longer shank allows the coupler head to shift toward the middle of the track, relieving sideways pressure.

With cars, the kingpins are usually nearer the end of the car and the length of the coupler shank isn’t a factor.

Even so, I would never install short couplers on long cars like 89-foot flats where the kingpin is a considerable distance inboard.

I could’ve used that offending car elsewhere in the train and it would’ve worked fine, but I don’t want a railroad with a lot of restrictions about which cars can go behind locomotives. If you’re trying to run prototypically, there’s already enough of that kind of thing. For example, you don’t run cars loaded with gasoline or other hazardous cargo right behind the locomotive.

Other derailment causes. The number one cause of derailments on my layout is low-hanging coupler pins. I don’t know how I manage to put cars out there without checking pin height, but I sometimes do. My standard is to clear the Micro-Trains height gauge and to clear it by a little extra. I don’t do any uncoupling over magnets, so the pins don’t need to be at the correct height for magnetic uncoupling. Some modelers don’t like the appearance of the pins and clip them off short, but they resemble air hoses well enough to suit me. Don’t pull them out altogether, or the coupler won’t work.

Give turnouts a fighting chance. Lots of derailments can be avoided before you ever run a train just by doing a good, careful job of laying track. The photo shows one of several locations that were prone to derailments because I wanted to make a passing track as long as possible. To achieve that end, I would lay track directly from a curve into the heel of a turnout.

The result was just enough derailments to drive me crazy, and I’d file and bend track to no avail. Finally, having pretty much filed the turnout to death, I’d replace it and move it so a locomotive had several inches of straight track to sort itself out before entering the turnout. It all goes back to that temptation to try to squeeze in a little too much.

With a bit more tinkering, I should banish most of the derailments from my layout. That should keep the operations chief happy.

Join the discussion

Read and share your comments on this article
Comment on this article
Want to leave a comment?
Only registered members of ModelRailroader.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Login or Register now.
0 comments
Layout Projects

Layout Projects

Tips and techniques for any layout

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Model Railroader Newsletter See all
Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter and get model railroad news in your inbox!
By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Model Railroader magazine. Please view our privacy policy