Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Model Railroader Readers Choice Winners

header


MRRRC0519_Page_1_Image_0001
WINNER: The HO MP15DC locomotive is available in DCC ready and DCC and sound-equipped versions.
HO SCALE DIESEL LOCOMOTIVE

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: HO MP15DC Locomotives

RUNNER UP | ScaleTrains.com: Rivet Counter GE Tier 4 GEVo

N SCALE DIESEL LOCOMOTIVE

WINNER | Broadway Limited Imports: EMD F3/F7

RUNNER UP | Kato Trains: EMD Milwaukee Road FP7 & F7B

HO SCALE STEAM LOCOMOTIVE

WINNER | Broadway Limited Imports: C&O J3a Greenbrier

RUNNER UP | Athearn Trains: CSA-1 and CSA-2 4-6-6-4

N SCALE STEAM LOCOMOTIVE

WINNER | Broadway Limited Imports: PRR T1

RUNNER UP | Athearn Trains: CSA-1 and CSA-2 4-6-6-4

TROLLEY, STREETCAR OR SUBWAY CAR - ANY SCALE

WINNER | Bachmann Trains: PCC with sparking pole and DCC sound

RUNNER UP | Bowser: PCC streetcars

ELECTRIC LOCOMOTIVE - ANY SCALE

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: HO ALP-45DP

RUNNER UP | Bachmann Trains: ACS-64 (with TCS WOWSound)

NARROW GAUGE LOCOMOTIVE

WINNER | Blackstone Models: HOn3 K-27 Mikado 2-8-2 “Mudhen”

RUNNER UP | Bachmann Trains: On30 2-6-0 (DCC-equipped sound ready)

S SCALE LOCOMOTIVE

WINNER | American Models: EMD GP9 standard

RUNNER UP | MTH Electric Trains: F3 locomotive



HO SCALE TRAIN SET

WINNER | Lionel Trains: The Polar Express HO Set

RUNNER UP | Bachmann Trains: The Greatest Show On Earth (Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey)

N SCALE TRAIN SET

WINNER | Bachmann Trains: Broadway Limited set

RUNNER UP | Kato Trains: Operation North Pole Christmas train 6-unit book case collector’s set



HO SCALE PASSENGER CAR

WINNER | Broadway Limited Imports: California Zephyr

RUNNER UP | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Proto 70-foot Heavyweight Railway Post Office-Baggage

MRRRC0519_Page_2_Image_0001
WINNER: The N Trainman 60-foot passenger cars are based on C&NW and CNJ prototypes.
N SCALE PASSENGER CARS

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: N Trainman passenger cars

RUNNER UP | Intermountain Railway Co.: 52-seat fluted-side coach

HO SCALE PASSENGER CAR SET

WINNER | Broadway Limited Imports: Wabash Blue Bird

RUNNER UP | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Proto George Washington C&O train

N SCALE PASSENGER CAR SET

WINNER | Kato Trains: Milwaukee Road Olympian Hiawatha 9-car train set

RUNNER UP | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: N Trainman 5-car passenger car set



MRRRC0519_Page_2_Image_0002
WINNER: Pre-1950 PS-1 boxcars 4328 ATSF. Pre-order today.
HO SCALE BOX CAR

WINNER | Kadee Quality Products Co.: ATSF pre-1950 PS-1 boxcar

RUNNER UP | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Mainline 60-foot high-cube Plate F boxcar

MRRRC0519_Page_2_Image_0003
WINNER: Kadee Quality Products Co.: 40-foot PS-1 boxcar kits 6-, 7- or 8-foot door cars.
HO SCALE BOX CAR KIT

WINNER | Kadee Quality Products Co.: 40-foot PS-1 boxcar kit

RUNNER UP | Accurail: Pullman-Standard 4750 covered hopper kit

N SCALE BOX CAR

WINNER | Broadway Limited Imports: NYC steel boxcar

RUNNER UP | Atlas Model Railroad Co. Inc.: N ATSF BX-177 boxcar

HO SCALE HOPPER CAR / COVERED HOPPER

WINNER | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Mainline 39-foot Trinity 3281 2-bay covered hopper

RUNNER UP | Broadway Limited Imports: H2a 3-bay hopper

N SCALE HOPPER CAR / COVERED HOPPER

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: N Trainman ACF 3560 covered hopper

RUNNER UP | ScaleTrains.com: Rivet Counter Gunderson 5188cf covered hopper

MRRRC0519_Page_3_Image_0001
WINNER: These striking TopGon models are available in single packs, 3-packs and 6-packs.
HO SCALE GONDOLA CAR

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: Norfolk Southern G-86R TopGon

RUNNER UP | ExactRail: Gunderson 7466 wood-chip gondola

N SCALE GONDOLA CAR

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: Norfolk Southern G-86R TopGon

RUNNER UP | Intermountain Railway Co.: Bathtub coal gondola

HO SCALE FLAT CAR / INTERMODAL

WINNER | Athearn Trains: Genesis F89 tri-level auto rack

RUNNER UP | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Mainline 60-foot Pullman-Standard flatcar

N SCALE FLAT CAR / INTERMODAL

WINNER | Athearn Trains: F89 bi-level/tri-level auto rack

RUNNER UP | Intermountain Railway Co.: 60-foot wood deck flatcar

MRRRC0519_Page_3_Image_0002
WINNER: Expand HO freight service in minutes with railroad-ready WalthersMainline 50-foot exterior-post mechanical refrigerator cars.
HO SCALE REFRIGERATOR CAR

WINNER | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Mainline 50-foot AAR mechanical refrigerator car

RUNNER UP | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: HO 40-foot wood reefer

N SCALE REFRIGERATOR CAR

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: N 40-foot wood reefer

RUNNER UP | Intermountain Railway Co.: R-40-23

HO SCALE TANK CAR

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: HO 11,000-gallon tank car

RUNNER UP | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Proto 55-foot Trinity modified 30,145- gallon tank car

N SCALE TANK CAR

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: 11,000-gallon tank car

RUNNER UP | Athearn Trains: Tank Train

HO SCALE CABOOSE / MAINTENANCE OF WAY

WINNER | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Proto Jordan Spreader

RUNNER UP | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: HO Trainman cupola caboose

N SCALE CABOOSE / MAINTENANCE OF WAY

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: N extended-cupola caboose

RUNNER UP | Micro-Trains Line Co.: 31-foot bay-window caboose

S SCALE ROLLING STOCK

WINNER | MTH Electric Trains: 40-foot wood-sided reefer – Columbia Soups

RUNNER UP | American Models: 40-foot Deluxe boxcar

NARROW GAUGE ROLLING STOCK

WINNER | Blackstone Models: D&RGW 30-foot refrigerator cars

RUNNER UP | Bachmann Trains: Derrick car



MRRRC0519_Page_3_Image_0003
WINNER: Cornerstone urban bridge kits fit industrial, commercial, and residential HO scenes in all popular eras.
HO SCALE STRUCTURE KITS

WINNER | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Cornerstone urban bridges

RUNNER UP | Bar Mills Scale Model Works: Chalky White’s Pool Hall

MRRRC0519_Page_4_Image_0001
WINNER: Build trackside business with the N Scale Cornerstone Central Beverage Distributors with office annex kit.
N SCALE STRUCTURE KITS

WINNER | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Cornerstone Central Beverage Distributors with office annex

RUNNER UP | Woodland Scenics: Fire station

O SCALE STRUCTURE KITS

WINNER | Bar Mills Scale Model Works: Shipyard Brewing

RUNNER UP | Woodland Scenics: County Store Expansion

HO SCALE BUILT-UP STRUCTURE

WINNER | Woodland Scenics: Letters, Parcels & Post

RUNNER UP | Bar Mills Scale Model Works: Operating Water Tower

N SCALE BUILT-UP STRUCTURE

WINNER | Woodland Scenics: Rustic Water Tower

RUNNER UP | Bar Mills Scale Model Works: Operating Water Tower

O SCALE BUILT-UP STRUCTURE

WINNER | Woodland Scenics: Old weathered barn

RUNNER UP | Bar Mills Scale Model Works: Operating Water Tower

MRRRC0519_Page_4_Image_0002
WINNER: SceneMaster UPS package cars come in two schemes and deliver great detail to HO layouts.
VEHICLES - ANY SCALE

WINNER | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: SceneMaster UPS package car

RUNNER UP | Awesome Diecast: Iconic Replicas Greyhound Bus Line motor coach

MRRRC0519_Page_4_Image_0003
WINNER: Put life in HO layouts with this contemporary railroad yard crew figure set from Walters SceneMaster.
FIGURES - ANY SCALE

WINNER | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: SceneMaster railroad yard crew

RUNNER UP | Woodland Scenics: Train Personnel



MRRRC0519_Page_4_Image_0004
WINNER: If you like the Zephyr Xtra, you’ll LOVE the Zephyr Express!
DCC, ELECTRONICS & CONTROLS

WINNER | Digitrax: Zephyr Xtra starter set

MRRRC0519_Page_5_Image_0001
RUNNER UP: A throttle, booster, and command station in one unit, the PowerCab is a user-friendly way to get started in DCC.
DCC, ELECTRONICS & CONTROLS

RUNNER UP | NCE Corporation: NCE PowerCab

MRRRC0519_Page_5_Image_0002
WINNER: Tsunami2 are available in steam, diesel, or electric versions.
DCC SOUND DECODER - FAVORITE BRAND

WINNER | Soundtraxx: Tsunami2 decoders

MRRRC0519_Page_5_Image_0003
RUNNER UP: Digitrax has decoders for ALL your locos – all sizes, shapes, and features!
DCC SOUND DECODER - FAVORITE BRAND

RUNNER UP | Digitrax: Digitrax Decoders

MRRRC0519_Page_5_Image_0004
WINNER: Rede”Fi”ne possibilities for your model railroad operations: Simplify ... WiFi ... LocoFi.
NON-DCC COMMAND CONTROL

WINNER | WiFi Model Railroad Co.: LocoFi

RUNNER UP | Bluerail Trains: BlueRail Trains Blue Horse

LAYOUT SOUND SYSTEMS

WINNER | Broadway Limited Imports: Rolling Thunder subwoofer system

RUNNER UP | SoundTraxx: SurroundTraxx DSP-80

MRRRC0519_Page_5_Image_0005
WINNER: Digitrax PS2012E: The best power supply on the market.
DCC POWER PACK

WINNER | Digitrax: 20 Amp Power Supply

RUNNER UP | Model Rectifier Corp.: Throttle Pack 9950

MRRRC0519_Page_5_Image_0006
WINNER: Wm. K. Walthers Inc. Layout Control System brings easy, affordable turnout control to HO, N, S, and O.
TRACK & SIGNAL CONTROL

WINNER | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: Wm. K. Walthers Inc.

RUNNER UP | Circuitron, Inc.: AR-2 automatic reverse circuit with delay

MRRRC0519_Page_5_Image_0007
RUNNER UP: Digitrax breakout boards make wiring Digitrax Logic boards a much easier task..
MISCELLANEOUS ELECTRONICS

WINNER | Broadway Limited Imports: Address Changer

RUNNER UP | ACCU-LITES: Breakout boards for Digitrax



READY-TO-INSTALL TREES

WINNER | Woodland Scenics: Premium trees

RUNNER UP | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: SceneMaster trees

SCENERY TOOLS

WINNER | Woodland Scenics: Static King

RUNNER UP | Wm. K. Walthers Inc.: SceneMaster tear and plant meadow mat

MRRRC0519_Page_5_Image_0008
RUNNER UP: Backdrop Junction supplies the highest quality in photo backdrops, personal custom service, and reasonable prices.
BACKDROPS

WINNER | RailroadBackdrops.com/Affordable Model Railroads: Custom backdrops

RUNNER UP | Backdrop Junction: Custom Backdrops



MRRRC0519_Page_7_Image_0001
RUNNER UP: Micro Engineering HO Code 83 Flex-Trak with wood grain detail and scale size spikes and tie plates.
HO SCALE FLEXTRACK

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: Code 100 & Code 83 flextrack

RUNNER UP | Micro Engineering: HO Scale Flex-Trak, weathered or non-weathered rail

N SCALE FLEXTRACK

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: Code 80 flextrack

RUNNER UP | Micro Engineering: Flex-Trak, weathered and non-weathered

HO SCALE SECTIONAL TRACK

WINNER | Kato Trains: Unitrack

RUNNER UP | Bachmann Trains: E-Z Track

HO SCALE TURNOUTS

WINNER | Pritchard Patent Product Co. Ltd. (Peco): Code 83 and 100 turnouts

RUNNER UP | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: Curved HO scale turnout

TRACK LAYING TOOLS

WINNER | Atlas Model Railroad Co.: Rail joiner sidekick tool

RUNNER UP | Fast Tracks: Assembly fixtures



FAVORITE BRICK & MORTAR HOBBY STORE (STOREFRONT) - NORTHEAST REGION

WINNER | MB Klein, Cockeysville, Md.

RUNNER UP | TrainLand, Lynbrook, N.Y.

FAVORITE BRICK & MORTAR HOBBY STORE (STOREFRONT) - SOUTHEAST REGION

WINNER | Little Choo Choo Shop, Spencer, N.C.

RUNNER UP | TrainMaster, Buford, Ga.

MRRRC0519_Page_7_Image_0002
RUNNER UP: Lombard Hobbies...Your HO & N Scale value pricing leader for over 40 years!
FAVORITE BRICK & MORTAR HOBBY STORE (STOREFRONT) - MIDWEST REGION

WINNER | Des Plaines Hobbies, Des Plaines, Ill.

RUNNER UP | Lombard Hobby Shop, Lombard, Ill.

FAVORITE BRICK & MORTAR HOBBY STORE (STOREFRONT) - SOUTHWEST REGION

WINNER | Discount Model Trains, Addison, Texas

RUNNER UP | An Affair with Trains, Phoenix, Ariz.

FAVORITE BRICK & MORTAR HOBBY STORE (STOREFRONT) - WESTERN REGION

WINNER | Caboose Hobbies, Lakewood, Colo.

RUNNER UP | The Original Whistle Stop, Pasadena, Calif.

FAVORITE ONLINE RETAILER (Does not require storefront)

WINNER | Walthers.com

RUNNER UP | ModelTrainStuff.com



ISEProtoThrottle
WINNER: Iowa Scaled Engineering’s ProtoThrottle, a wireless handheld DCC control stand throttle. The ultimate prototypical control!
MOST INNOVATIVE MODEL RAILROAD PRODUCT OF 2018

WINNER | Iowa Scaled Engineering - Proto Throttle

MRRRC0519_Page_7_Image_0004
RUNNER UP: The Micro Engineering HO Ladder Track System for compact yards, utilizes five #5 turnouts, 5a thru 5e.
MOST INNOVATIVE MODEL RAILROAD PRODUCT OF 2018

RUNNER UP | Micro-Engineering Ladder System

Join the discussion

Read and share your comments on this article
FREE PDF

FREE PDF

Plan and design an around the room track plan.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Model Railroader Newsletter See all
Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter and get model railroad news in your inbox!
By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Model Railroader magazine. Please view our privacy policy