Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Kato N scale Metra train set

Read this review from Model Railroader
Kato N scale Metra train set
Kato N scale Metra train set
Including a sleek MotivePower MP36PH-3S and fluted silver Nippon-Sharyo gallery coaches, this N scale train set from Kato captures a sight familiar to millions of Chicago-area residents. The MP36 should also be a welcome addition to any N scalers looking for a contemporary commuter locomotive. The well-detailed Kato MP36PH-3S and coaches are available separately or in a boxed set that includes the locomotive, two coaches, and a cab-coach.

New century, new equipment. Operated under the Illinois Rapid Transit Authority, Metra is one of the busiest commuter railroads in the United States. By 2000 Metra needed to replace some of its aging fleet of locomotives and cars, many of which were received secondhand from other railroads.

Between 2002 and 2005 Japanese railcar manufacturer Nippon-Sharyo delivered 192 bi-level coaches and 108 cab-coaches to Metra for push-pull operations. Each coach has a seating capacity of 145 passengers, while a cab-coach can seat 138. The cars are assigned throughout the Metra system.

In 2003 Metra received 27 new MP36PH-3S diesel-electric locomotives. The model number designates that the locomotive was built by MotivePower (MP), has a 3,600 hp engine (36), is designed for passenger service (P), has a head-end power alternator (H), has microprocessor controls (3), and a static inverter system (S). The locomotives are currently assigned to Metra’s BNSF, Milwaukee, and Rock Island Districts.

The MP36PH-3S is part of MotivePower’s MPXpress product line that includes other variations, such as the 4,000 hp MP40. MPXpress locomotives are used on several other commuter railroads including New Mexico’s Rail Runner and the Washington, D.C.-area Virginia Railway Express (VRE).

The dimensions of the Kato MP36 match prototype drawings in the March 2008 issue of Railroad Model Craftsman. I couldn’t find drawings for the cars, but the length, width, and height of the models match prototype specifications on the Nippon-Sharyo website.
The Kato MP36PH-3S and the Nippon-Sharyo cab coach both feature directional headlights and marker lights. The number boards are also illuminated
The Kato MP36PH-3S and the Nippon-Sharyo cab coach both feature directional headlights and marker lights. The number boards are also illuminated.
Locomotive details. The locomotive’s plastic body shell has crisp molded detail. The air horn, cab steps, and rear handrails are separate plastic parts.

The Kato MP36 accurately models the paint scheme of the Metra prototype. The separation between the colors is razor sharp. I was especially impressed by the gradient from gray to blue on the sides of the locomotive.

The molded handrails along the cab doors are painted the same colors as the body. The handrails would look better as separate parts, since then they could have been painted white to match the prototype Metra MP36.
The coaches have upper and lower level interiors and tinted window glazing. Kato sells interior lighting kits that work on DC and DCC layouts
The coaches have upper and lower level interiors and tinted window glazing. Kato sells interior lighting kits that work on DC and DCC layouts.
Coach details. The plastic coaches have crisp molded-in detail and lettering that matches prototype photos. The IRTA logo is visible under magnification. The safety stripes on the cab end of the cab coach are also correctly placed with sharp separation between the colors.

The prototype coaches have regular windows surrounded by a black gasket and emergency windows that have removable metal frames. The Kato models match the prototype window arrangement except for the cab end of the cab-coach. The positions of the endmost emergency window and regular window on the lower level are opposite that of the prototype.

I used a hobby knife to carefully spread the sides of the body shell apart, so that I could lift it off the frame. I’ve ridden these cars many times, and the interior arrangement looks correct. The upper and lower interiors are molded separately. The window glazing has a greenish tint that’s similar to the tinting on the prototype’s windows.
Kato N scale MP36
Performance. Before lifting off the locomotive’s plastic body shell, I removed the rear handrails. Under the body shell, a split die-cast metal frame encloses the motor and flywheels. A plastic cover holds the printed-circuit (PC) board in place on top of the frame.

The Kato MP36 has a mechanism that’s smooth and quiet at all speeds. The model’s top speed of 200 scale mph is quite a bit higher than the prototype, which could attain 108 mph. Metra coaches have a top speed limited to 79 mph, and the actual operating speed is usually much lower than that.

I ran the train around the 12" curves of our N scale test layout without difficulty. The lights in the locomotive and cab coach didn’t flicker when the train negotiated the layout’s no. 6 turnouts.
Train Control Systems sells a six-function DCC decoder designed for the Kato MP36. For more information on the decoder, visit www.tcsdcc.com.

Lighting options.
The prototypical lighting on the locomotive and cab coach are my favorite features of this set. The headlights and the marker lights on both the locomotive and cab coach operate according to the train’s direction. There’s a lighting on/off switch on the underframe of the cab coach.
The backup light and strobe light on the MP36 are non-operational. A TCS lighting kit (K4-LK) that adds these functions when used in conjunction with the K4D6 DCC decoder is available.

Kato sells interior lighting kits for the coaches that operate on DC or DCC layouts. Adding a Kato FR11 decoder to each car allows operators to turn the
interior lights on or off with a DCC throttle. The FR12 decoder is made specifically for the cab-coach and provides independent control of the headlights and markers when using DCC. See the Kato website for more information.

With the release of these accurately detailed models, Kato has made it easier than ever to model Metra commuter service in N scale.

For more N scale product reviews, track plans, and videos, visit the Model Railroader N scale page.
Price: $185 (set), $120 (MP36), $30 (coach), $35 (cab coach)

Manufacturer
Kato USA Inc.
100 Remington Rd.
Schaumburg, IL 60173
katousa.com

Era: 2003 to present

Road names: Chicago METRA, Virginia Railway Express (VRE)

Locomotive features
  • All-wheel drive and electrical pickup
  • Blackened metal wheels in gauge
  • Body-mounted magnetic knuckle couplers at correct height (with modeler-installed trip pins)
  • Five-pole skew-wound motor with dual brass flywheels
  • Light-emitting diode (LED)headlights, marker lights, and number boards
  • Weight: 4.5 ounces
Car features
  • Blackened metal wheels in gauge
  • Cab-coach has directional LED headlight and marker lights
  • Truck-mounted magnetic knuckle couplers at correct height (with modeler-installed trip pins)
  • Weight: 1.25 ounces (coach), 1.5 ounces (cab-coach). The cab-coach is .1 ounce too heavy and the coach is .15 ounce too light per National Model Railroad Association RP-20.1

Join the discussion

Read and share your comments on this article
Comment on this article
Want to leave a comment?
Only registered members of ModelRailroader.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Login or Register now.
0 comments
Layout Projects

Layout Projects

Tips and techniques for any layout

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Model Railroader Newsletter See all
Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter and get model railroad news in your inbox!
By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Model Railroader magazine. Please view our privacy policy