Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Broadway Limited Imports HO scale PRR class H10s 2-8-0 steam locomotive

Read this review from Model Railroader magazine
BroadwayLimitedImportsLLCPRR280steamlocomotive
Broadway Limited Imports LLC PRR 2-8-0 steam locomotive
A superb Pennsylvania RR class H10s 2-8-0 Consolidation has been released in HO scale by Broadway Limited Imports. It’s offered decorated in multiple road numbers with a choice of prototypical tenders. The model features BLI’s dual-mode Paragon2 sound decoder which provides smooth operation on both direct-current (DC) and Digital Command Control (DCC) layouts.

The 2-8-0 Consolidation was the most common freight locomotive operating on the Pennsylvania RR during the early 20th century. By 1924, the company owned 11 classes of 2-8-0s that included 3,335 locomotives.

The 273 class H10s Consolidations came from four locomotive builders, the Baldwin, Brooks, Lima, and Pittsburgh locomotive companies, between 1913 and 1916. The H10s class engines were the largest of the PRR’s 2-8-0s, and many remained in service into the 1950s. A second group of 200 H10s conversions soon followed as the PRR’s Juniata Shop upgraded a group of older, but similar size, class H8 locomotives with larger
cylinders and superheaters to match the H10s.

All of the H10s locomotives measured just under 70 feet long with tender, and all of them included the Pennsy’s signature Belpaire firebox. As PRR’s dieselization took hold, many Consolidations were sold off to the PRR’s neighbors and subsidiaries for continued service.
Thelocomotivetenderincludesabackuplightandmarkers
The locomotive tender includes a backup light and markers.
The model. Broadway Limited’s H10s model matches the dimensions shown in a prototype plan published in the Model Railroader Cyclopedia: Vol. 1, Steam Locomotives. A single printed sheet of exploded isometric drawings shows the model’s construction.

The die-cast boiler includes a backhead that conceals a can motor within the firebox. The ABS plastic cab slips over the backhead to shelter the cab interior and the engine crew. A slide switch under the cab turns a smoke unit on or off.

Our sample came neatly painted in the PRR’s freight colors of “almost black” Dark Green Locomotive Enamel (DGLE), with a graphite smokebox and firebox. The cab roof and tender deck are red. The Dulux Gold Pennsylvania tender lettering and engine cab number are neatly applied in the proper font.

Mechanism. The H10s has a die-cast metal locomotive chassis that provides additional weight for traction. The heart of the mechanism is a can motor with a brass flywheel that delivers smooth operation. Traction tires on the two rear drivers give the H10s a drawbar pull equivalent to 45 free-rolling HO scale freight cars on straight and level track.

All of the drivers and wheelsets match the National Model Railroad Association standards. The model’s steady electrical pickup kept the lights and sound constant through crossings, uneven track, and no. 5 and 6 turnouts.

The chemically blackened metal Walschaerts valve gear moves smoothly. The sound and smoke effects are
mechanically synchronized and vary with the load.

The tender has an ABS plastic body shell mounted on a die-cast metal frame. Its floor casting includes a circular grill that protects a downward-facing speaker mounted inside a sound box. The Paragon2 dual-mode sound decoder rides on top of the speaker enclosure. An 8-pin plug connects the decoder to the locomotive beneath the cab footplate. A folding cab apron spans the scale 2-foot gap between the engine and tender.

Two tenders are available. Our sample came with the class 80F81 Lines West high-side tender. A shorter class 90F82 Lines East tender is also available.
HOscalePRRclassH10s280
DCC operation. The model performed smoothly with the decoder set to 28 speed steps. With its decoder set to 128 speed steps, the model crept along at 1 scale mph in speed step 1. The decoder includes many programmable configuration variables (CVs) that allow you to fine-tune locomotive performance, including custom speed tables and adjustable momentum. A printed operator’s manual is included with the model, and a more extensive technical manual is available as a free download at www.broadway-limited.com.

Highlights of the user-triggered sound effects include a realistic PRR “banshee” whistle, bell, couplers engaging, and coupler slack being let out when the train starts moving. The number of times the latter effect plays and the interval between each is adjustable with CVs 178 and 179, which is helpful for simulating a longer train starting out.

When the locomotive is under way, the intensity of the exhaust varies automatically with the load. It can also be adjusted “on the fly” using function keys 5 and 6 on a DCC throttle to simulate the heavy chuff of a locomotive starting or heading upgrade as well as the hissing “drift” chuffs of a locomotive running light or coasting down a grade. In either case, the exhaust is perfectly timed, along with the puffing smoke, to four chuffs per wheel revolution throughout the locomotive’s speed range.

Function 0 triggers the lights. The headlight and backup light turn on automatically according the locomotive’s
direction, which isn’t prototypical. When stopped the lights automatically dim, and the cab interior light illuminates. The dimmer and cab light can be programmed for manual operation via function keys.

The model includes marker lights on the tender and locomotive pilot beam. The latter shouldn’t be confused with classification lights. The markers have red lenses facing out and yellow lenses facing to the sides. On the prototype, the markers could show either aspect but were usually adjusted to show yellow to the sides and in the direction of travel and red to the end opposite the direction of travel. The model includes extra user-installed lenses in each color, so the aspects can be changed. The lights would normally be illuminated at night only when the locomotive traveled light or pushed on the rear of a train. However, the markers on the model are always
illuminated without any on/off control.

The H10s includes the unique Paragon2 macro recording feature. I recorded the H10s starting out and heading down the main line with appropriate whistle signals. When I finished recording, I pressed function 27 and the locomotive ran on auto pilot while I operated another train.

DC operation. The BLI H10s will run with only a DC power pack. Both the directional headlights and synchronized smoke operate in DC. However, the sound effects are limited to the steam exhaust, squealing brakes, and random effects like the air pump.

To get the most from the model on a DC layout, I recommend using a BLI DCMaster Analog Control Module or an MRC Tech 6 DC sound controller. Either of these devices will allow access to sound effects and other functions, as well as some programming capability.

On our DC test track the model didn’t start moving until I advanced the power pack to 9 volts. I improved the
locomotive’s DC performance by programming CV252 (analog starting voltage) to a value of 70 and CV131 (analog sound start voltage) to a value of 1. The model then started moving smoothly at 7 volts.

Pennsy fans have been waiting for an HO scale H10s. They now have one that sounds as good as it looks.
Price: $449.99

Manufacturer
Broadway Limited Imports LLC
9 East Tower Circle
Ormond Beach, FL 37174
www.broadway-limited.com

Road numbers/versions
  • Pennsylvania RR with Lines West high-side tender: nos. 8022, 8304, 8421, 9915
  • PRR with Lines East tender: nos. 8014, 8259, 9422
  • Long Island H10s with high-side tender: nos. 108 and 110
  • Lines West and Lines East versions available painted DGLE but unlettered/unnumbered
Era (as detailed): 1920s to late 1950s

Features
  • Dual-mode Paragon 2 decoder and sound system
  • Electrical pickup on six drivers and all tender wheels
  • Golden white LED headlight and backup light
  • Illuminated marker lights and cab interior light
  • Metal Kadee-compatible couplers, at correct height
  • Minimum radius: 18"
  • Operates on code 70 rail
  • RP-25 contour metal wheels, in gauge
  • Synchronized smoke unit
  • Traction tires on rear drivers
  • Weight: 14 ounces (engine alone: 10 ounces)

Join the discussion

Read and share your comments on this article
Comment on this article
Want to leave a comment?
Only registered members of ModelRailroader.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Login or Register now.
0 comments
Layout Projects

Layout Projects

Tips and techniques for any layout

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Model Railroader Newsletter See all
Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter and get model railroad news in your inbox!
By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Model Railroader magazine. Please view our privacy policy