Subscriber & Member Login

Login, or register today to interact in our online community, comment on articles, receive our newsletter, manage your account online and more!

Athearn Genesis GP50 diesel locomotive

Read this review from Model Railroader magazine
AthearnGenesisGP50diesellocomotives
Athearn Genesis GP50 diesel locomotives
Not to be confused with the earlier Ready-to-Roll model, this Genesis-series GP50 from Athearn features all-new tooling for both Phase I and Phase II versions and many prototype-specific details. Our test samples came equipped with feature-laden SoundTraxx Digital Command Control decoders. A DC version with a DCC socket that accepts 8- or 9-pin decoders is also available.

The prototype.
Meant to be a replacement for the 3,000 hp GP40-2 in General Motors’ Electro-Motive Division product line, the GP50 boasted a 3,500 hp 645F3 turbocharged diesel engine, new D87 traction motors, and other improvements. Problems with the new engine and lackluster sales kept the production run short. Only 278 GP50s were built compared to 1,143 GP40-2s.

The first 50 locomotives went to the Chicago & North Western Ry. in May 1980. The Southern Ry. had the largest fleet, rostering 90 high-short hood GP50s. The Missouri Pacific RR was the only road to order its GP50s without dynamic brakes. The Burlington Northern RR’s GP50 roster included nine that were originally ordered by the St. Louis – San Francisco Ry. prior to its purchase by the BN in 1980.

In 1985, EMD made external modifications to the GP50 design. Railfans and modelers refer to these as Phase II and the earlier units as Phase I. The Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. and BN purchased both Phase I and Phase II GP50s.

Many GP50s now wear the livery of post-merger railroads, such as BNSF and Norfolk Southern. Union Pacific inherited GP50s from the CNW and MoPac.
BacktobackGP50s
The Athearn Trains Genesis series EMD GP50 diesel locomotives are available in Phase I (left) and Phase II (right) versions.
BoththeCNWPhaseIandSantaFePhaseIIversionsfeatureaccurateprototypespecificdetailsBothmodelshaveoperatingcabroofbeacons
Both the C&NW (Phase I) and Santa Fe (Phase II) versions feature accurate prototype-specific details. Both models have operating cab-roof beacons.
The model. We reviewed a Phase I GP50 decorated for CNW no. 5056 delivered in 1980 and a Phase II version decorated for Santa Fe no. 3849 delivered in 1985. Phase I and II GP50s have the same dimensions, and both Athearn models match prototype drawings of a Phase I GP50 in the November/December 1980 issue of Mainline Modeler.

The models accurately depict all the differences between Phase I and II GP50s. The Phase I model has a stepped side sill, sharper angled rear anticlimber, and the wide “mailbox” style blower duct behind the cab. Details on the Phase II version include the straight side sill, shallower angled rear anticlimber, and narrower, angled blower duct.

ThePhaseIanticlimberhasasharperanglethanitsPhaseIIcounterpart
The Phase I anticlimber has a sharper angle than its Phase II counterpart.
The models have plastic body shells with wire grab irons and plastic detail parts. The 3,600 gallon fuel tanks feature separate piping. Prototype-specific details include the gong bell on the front of the CNW unit and the cab roof antenna platform on the SF unit.

The acetal plastic handrails have scale profiles, but several of the stanchions came loose on our samples. Modelers may want to add a touch of cyanoacrylate adhesive to keep these parts in place.

Both paint schemes match prototype photos. Santa Fe no. 3849 correctly has the brake ratchet recess painted blue. Santa Fe units delivered in 1981 had this space painted yellow.

Separate parts on the model’s plastic truck sideframes include brake cylinders. The HO scale trucks match drawings of the prototype’s Blomberg-M trucks in the Mainline Modeler article.

Mechanism. After removing the coupler boxes, I carefully lifted off the locomotive shell. The model’s mechanism is the same as that of other recent Athearn Genesis Geeps. The motor and flywheels are in the middle of a die-cast metal frame with additional metal weights at each end of the frame.

The printed-circuit (PC) board and DCC decoder is mounted on top of the motor, and the single round speaker enclosure is attached to the top of the rear weight. Wires run from the PC board to the headlight assemblies. Athearn uses incandescent micro light bulbs for the headlights. I like the realistic yellowish glow that the bulbs provide compared to white light-emitting diodes found in other models. However, the bulbs are more likely than LEDs to burn out over time and need replacement.

The model’s all-wheel pickup kept the sounds and lights on without interruption as I ran it through the no. 6 yard turnouts on our layout. The acetal plastic sand lines at the front and rear of each truck cleared all of our code 83 track, turnouts, and grade crossings.

The GP50 has respectable pulling power for a four-axle diesel. The locomotive should be able to handle 37 HO freight cars on straight and level track.

In our hill-climbing test the GP50 pulled 11 HO freight cars up a 3 percent grade without slipping and stalling.

AthearnGenesisHOscaleGP50
DC operation. I tested the model with a 12-volt (V) DC power pack. Like other dual-mode sound-equipped locomotives, the GP50 required a lot of voltage to start moving (7.5V), but it accelerated smoothly. The top speed of 100 scale mph is higher than that of the prototype, which could be geared for a top speed as high as 77 mph.

When running on a DC layout, the GP50’s lights turn on and engine goes through a start-up sequence then idles at 7V. The engine rpms increase gradually to notch 8 as I advanced the throttle from 7.5 to 12V.

When changing direction, it’s important not to reduce the throttle below 7V or the sound will shut off. The bell turns on automatically at speeds below 20 scale mph (8.5V). A quick increase of the throttle triggered a grade-crossing signal. With some practice I could time the signal to blow as the engine approached and passed through the crossing.

DCC operation. The GP50 performed reliably in DCC, thanks to its excellent SoundTraxx decoder. During testing I ran and programmed the model with a Digitrax Zephyr, NCE Powercab, and MRC Prodigy Advance. I also advance consisted our GP50 samples to run as a multiple unit (m.u.) set.

An extensive user manual that lists all the programmable configuration variables (CVs) supported by the SoundTraxx decoder is available at www.soundtraxx.com. Following these instructions I easily fine-tuned the performance of our samples. I added momentum for more realistic starts and stops. I also chose one of the 14 preset speed tables that gave me finer control of the locomotive at slower speeds.

The SoundTraxx decoder does a great job capturing the sound of a turbocharged EMD 645. I appreciated that I could fine tune the engine sounds. For example CV 116 sets the number of speed steps per engine notch. The engine sounds can also be set for manual notching, where the engine rpm are controlled with function keys independently of the locomotive’s speed.

User-triggered functions include the bell, horn, and dynamic brake fans. Both the CNW and Santa Fe versions have operating roof beacons that are controlled by function 6.

With the GP50, Athearn continues its Genesis-series tradition of providing a superdetailed, prototype-specific model right out of the box. The realistic effects provided by the SoundTraxx decoder make it a fun locomotive to run on both DC and especially DCC layouts.
Price: $269.98 (DCC sound), $169.98 (DC no sound)

Manufacturer
Athearn Trains
1600 Forbes Way, Ste. 120
Long Beach, CA 90810
www.athearn.com

Era: 1980 (Phase I) or 1985 (Phase II) to present

Road names (multiple road numbers available): Phase I: Chicago & North Western, Missouri Pacific, Norfolk Southern (high short hood), Southern (high short hood), Union Pacific. Phase II: Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe; Burlington Northern (tiger stripe); BNSF (Heritage I scheme). Undecorated versions of both phases available.

Features
  • All-wheel drive and electrical pickup
  • Five-pole skew-wound motor with dual brass flywheels
  • McHenry operating knuckle couplers at correct height
  • Minimum radius: 18"
  • RP-25 contour metal wheels work on codes 70, 83, and 100 track
  • SoundTraxx dual-mode DCC sound decoder (DCC version only)
  • Weight: 14 ounces

Join the discussion

Read and share your comments on this article
Comment on this article
Want to leave a comment?
Only registered members of ModelRailroader.com are allowed to comment on this article. Registration is FREE and only takes a couple minutes.

Login or Register now.
0 comments
FREE DOWNLOAD

FREE DOWNLOAD

Add more operational possibilities to your layout.

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Model Railroader Newsletter See all
Sign up for our FREE e-newsletter and get model railroad news in your inbox!
By signing up you may also receive occasional reader surveys and special offers from Model Railroader magazine. Please view our privacy policy